Lenovo Yoga Tablet 8 – Mystical, Under-Promised & Over Delivered

I bought this €229 Android (4.2 Jelly Bean) tablet a few weeks ago and gave you my first impressions of it when it was delivered.  I thought it was good back then, and to quote 49ers head coach Jim Harbaugh, I think it is freakin’ mystical now.

This is not a product tablet.  This is a pure consumption tablet.  Lenovo’s designers sat down and decided to produce a lightweight device that was for surfing, social media, occasional emails, and for travel entertainment.  I think that last one was very important to them.

You’ll not that there’s an unusual cylinder along the edge of the device.  This is the battery.  It allowed Lenovo to do several things:

  • Put in a larger battery than usual (more later).
  • A mini kick stand rotates out of the back of the tablet for when you want to watch video or rest the device down.
  • The very thin device is formed to provide a comfortable hand grip for when you hold the device in portrait mode.

image

The form factor works perfectly.  I’ve had it resting on the kickstand almost all of the time since I got the tablet.  And it sits very nicely on an airplane tray/table allowing me to watch a movie even when I have a meal in front of me.

The build is an aluminium frame and lower half, and a high quality textured plastic (not tacky Samsung plastic) upper back.  The screen is excellent – 1280 * 800 is perfectly acceptable on an 8” device.  It’s all about pixels per inch rather than pixel counts when you are talking about display, as any professional printer will tell you.  device is solid.

The processor is running at just 1.2 GHz but that’s a deliberate choice by Lenovo to provide better battery life.  It runs Plants VS Zombies 2 perfectly fine and I am not planning on running AutoCAD on this thing.  It is a companion device designed for consumption, which Lenovo got 100% correct in my opinion.

Why did I buy this tablet when I was going to get a Windows tablet for work?  I had no plans on buying it.  But then I saw it on the Lenovo site and saw the battery life: “Up to 16 hours”.  That got me straight away.  Imagine flying to the USA west coast from Europe with a hop through London, without fearing that the battery would die half way there.  No running to find the 3 power sockets in the terminal at Chicago O’Hare.  No squeezing out the last drop of juice at the gate in Heathrow before boarding the 747.  The promise was too much. How did it do?

Last week I flew from Berlin to San Francisco via London Heathrow.  That’s a 1.5 hour hop followed by an 11+ hours flight, with 3 hours in London.  The battery was at 100% when I left the hotel in Berlin.  I used the tablet in airplane mode to watch video for almost every second of the flight, probably around 11 hours of video play time.  I did not go near a power socket on the journey.  I checked into my hotel in San Francisco and the battery was at 54%.  When you do the maths, the tablet would have played video for 23 hours!!!

What!!!!  23 hours of video play potential.  That promised 16 hours is a lie.  A good lie by marketing!!!!  I’ve talked with some of my fellow MVPs about this and we’re in agreement – we think Lenovo played it very safe, promising a still amazing “up to 16 hours” and delivering way beyond this.  Who would believe a statement of “up to 23 hours”?  Does this tablet drain power from dark matter in the cosmos?  By the way, the Yoga Tablet 10 has a bigger battery and promises “up to 18 hours”.

The only downside I can find are the speakers.  Every portable device will suck in comparison with the HTC One (Android phone) on this front.  I have no idea how HTC manage to do what they have done.  The speakers on the Yoga are tinny.  I cranked up the output using the supplied Dolby app.  But to be honest, my Bose headphones are plugged in most of the time, and the laptop’s volume only needed to be on 8/14 during a flight for perfect loudness.

I’ve been using the Yoga during my sleep deprived jetlag zombie hours while over here.  Surfing (Dolphin), social media (Facebook and Tweetcaster), media (Netflix and MX Player), all work superbly.  I’ve checked into flights, used the alarm, and kept up email.  Whatever I want, it’s there in the Google Play store.  And the tablet is siting on the kickstand by the bed whenever I wake up at the wee hours of the morning.

I am blown away by the Lenovo Yoga Tablet 8.  It contrasts 100% with my poor quality experience with the Dell Venue 8 Pro.  To me, the Lenovo Tablet 8 has set the bar for a mini consumption tablet.  The form factor, the quality, the build, don’t forget the huge Android app catalog, and the price make this a player in the market that you cannot overlook.

Technorati Tags:

Dell Venue 8 Pro – First and LAST Impressions

While in the USA, I picked up this Windows 8.1 8” tablet at Fry’s in Renton, just south of Bellevue/Redmond in Washington State.  My intention is to use a Windows 8.1 tablet as a presentation device for the next few years.  It would connect via Miracast to a Viewsonic WPG-370, which then outputs via VHA or HDMI to a display device such as a projector.

I got the tablet.  It’s a little thicker than a mid-level Android tablet, such as the Lenovo Yoga Tablet 8, or an iPad Mini, but I forgive that because it is a Bay Trail device running Windows 8.1 (not RT).  The texture of the back is nice for holding.  Performance seemed much better than Clover Trail devices of the previous generation.  The display seemed fine.  Battery is on the weaker side, promising up to 10 hours, but offering less than that if you turn off the ever annoying auto screen brightness.

And so that leads me to the problem.  You need to charge this device.  I tried to charge it on Wednesday morning.  Nothing.  No indications in Windows.  No lights.  In fact … the centre receiver in the micro/mini-USB port in the tablet felt a little loose.  I double checked everything by using another power socket, lead, and charger.  Nothing.  I had enough just left to run hardware tests and update the firmware.  Nothing.  This tablet already had an issue.

In the end, I had to sit in traffic for 2 hours to return the device on the Thursday night after my final meetings.  Luckily (I’ll get to that) Fry’s didn’t have any more of this model in stock and I got the credit returned to my card.

Why luckily?  In my experience, the hardware problem that I had indicates a manufacturing or design flaw.  I have seen this sort of thing before in disk caddies.  The central receiver in the port is not soldered sufficiently enough to the board to sustain normal wear and tear.  It becomes lose and then won’t pass power to the board.  This makes me think that the Dell Venue 8 Pro has a serious design/manufacturing flaw that will lead to lots of returned devices in the coming months.  This is bad for Windows because this was only the second device of this type to become generally available after the widely disliked Acer W3 tablet (awful screen).  This gives a false impression that Windows 8.1 mini tablets cannot be good hardware.  Fortunately for Microsoft, Dell are not yet shipping the Venue 8 Pro worldwide.  It was restricted to the USA (and in limited numbers) this time last week when I last checked.

As I said, I will be switching to a Toshiba Encore.  That device will be shipping very soon and is of a much higher spec.  Note the “up to 14 hours” battery life, meaning with non-adjusted screen brightness you might get 10-12 hours which is the sweet spot.  I know that Toshiba see this as a very important device and they have not rushed it out.  I look forward to spending some time on it.

Technorati Tags: ,

First Impressions of Lenovo Yoga Tablet 8

Last Sunday morning, I was lying in bed in Rome, surfing the web and looking to see if Lenovo had started selling the new Yoga 2 in Ireland.  I saw something that caught my attention – a new tablet with 18 hours battery life!  Whoah!

I dug a little deeper and saw that Lenovo had just launched the Yoga Tablet 10 (up to 18 hours battery) and the Yoga Tablet 8 (up to 16 hours battery).  Both had low horsepower 1.2 GHz MTK quad-core ARM processors running Android Jelly Bean 4.2.  There’s 1 GB RAM and 16 GB internal storage with micro SD expansion.  The display is a 1280 * 800 IPS – not retina but fine enough for me.

But this is not the usual tablet.  Look at my photo – this thing is standing up by itself.

image

What Lenovo appear to have done is designed a tablet for the person who is travelling a lot and is tired of hunting for that power supply that is used by the cleaners in the airport.

image

The bulge at the bottom serves several purposes:

  • It is a rotating hinge (with just the right amount of friction) for a mini-kickstand.
  • This bulge contains the battery.  Combined with just 1.2 GHz CPU, this is how the device gets long battery life.
  • A low centre of gravity keeps the device stable when stood up.
  • If feels like a nice grip when held in portrait mode for reading.  There is an ergonomic slope to the grip for your fingers.

Don’t get me wrong; this is not a productivity device.  Anyone who thinks this type of device is for running Office is a muppet.  This is a consumption device.  It’s for the sofa while watching TV, for watching video while travelling, for checking your email or posting on social networks.  It does have Bluetooth 4.0 and supports a keyboard but you’ll not see me doing that!  There is Miracast support, by the way.

I went for the 8 inch version because that, to me, is the perfect size of a companion tablet.  I have a 16 GB Micro SD plugged into it at the moment with some videos and the picture looks very good.

Price:

  • 8” is €229.99 or 269.99 for the 3G version.
  • the 10” is €289.99 or €329.99 for the 3G version.

At that price, the device must feel cheap in your hands, right?  WRONG!  There is some textured plastic like material on the back, but it feels like a quality material rather than the “Samsung plastic”.  But the majority of the device is aluminium, and the build feels very solid out of the box.  We’ll see how the hinge holds up after 6 months!

Any negatives?  Yes; the speakers are wimpy.  My HTC One phone shames most devices when it comes to speakers but it stomps all over the sound coming out of the Yoga Tablet.  That doesn’t bother me too much; I use Bose headphones when travelling.

I’m travelling quite a bit in the next two weeks (Dublin > Berlin > San Francisco > Seattle > Dublin) so I’ll be putting the Yoga Tablet to the test.  You’ll probably see a few tweets about it during that time.

Note: I am still getting a Windows 8” tablet.  Microsoft would murder me if I used an Android device at one of their events :)  Right now, the 64GB Dell Venue Pro 8 with stylus is my leading candidate.

Here’s Why I Cancelled My Xbox One Pre-Order

Sadly, I cancelled my Xbox One pre-order this morning.  I’d been thinking about this for a few weeks but 2 things pushed me over the edge over the last 24 hours.  Let me summarize all of the reasons:

Games

I don’t play a wide variety of games.  Madden lost me a few versions ago as the controls became over-fiddly.  Most of my gaming time has gone into Rockstar titles, including GTA IV and add-ons, Red Dead Redemption, and GTA V.  I detest random maze first person shooters, from Castle Wolfenstein onwards.  None of the titles for Xbox One grabs my interest.

Performance

I, like many, own a HD TV.  It cost me good money so I like to use feeds that offer 1080p.  It was a real kicker that games companies are announcing that their Xbox One versions will be crippled to 720p because they hardware just can’t keep up.  This morning, I read that Dead Rising 3 will not only be limited to 720p, but will also only run at 30 frames per second instead of the normally expected 60 FPS.   This is where the moron will comment that Dead Rising 3 is the sort of game that I just said I don’t play – true, but it is indicative that this hardware is insufficient for what it is being asked to do.

Clearly, the PS4 is trouncing the Xbox One as a games console.  That’s the purpose of the machine – I couldn’t give a flying fiddlers about Skype/streaming on Xbox because:

  • I rather do social media on a tablet/phone where I have comfort
  • Hardly any services exist outside of the USA
  • My Roku is waaaaay more reliable and simpler for media playback than anything Microsoft has offered so far

The Price

Xbox is inferior hardware to the PS4 – I’m not going to debate that because the results are already in.  The PS4 is $100/€100 cheaper.  Hmm.

Xbox sales started off slow due to stupid restriction policies that were later cancelled.  Then sales went up.  Now I am hearing anecdotal evidence that pre-order cancellations are rocketing.  It seems logical that if you do want to stick with the Xbox platform through the next generation, then you should wait until February when Microsoft will probably be forced to look at unbundling the Kinect and/or reducing the price.

Until then, I’m not willing to spend €500 for inferior hardware.

The Future of Xbox

You would think that Microsoft makes a fortune on Xbox.  The brand is very successful.  Gamers and non-gamers of different generations recognise the brand. Xbox loses a fortune for Microsoft every year.  I read last night that the $2billion/year that Microsoft makes from Android might be used to hide the Xbox losses (as well as those of Bing).  Wow!

I think there are three possible paths Microsoft might take with Xbox:

  1. Do nothing: This is what I call the Vista strategy.  Pretend that everything is fine and keep putting up blog posts to say something like “no, you’re the one with the performance issue”.
  2. Sell/Dump Xbox: Microsoft analyst, Rick Sherlund, says that Microsoft needs to sell off Xbox (and Bing).  If a new CEO does inspect the books and the headlines, then Xbox will look like a gangrenous limb that needs to be amputated.  Xbox is the very public brand that highlights many of the issues in Microsoft right now.
  3. Release Xbox One Point One: Can you imagine the hatred from Xbox One customers if Microsoft released a new console that had the hardware capable of doing what Microsoft is asking of it?  It’s possible that Microsoft could do this – but unlikely I think.

Under Ballmer, history shows us that path one will be taken (EDIT: It was).  What happens with a new CEO?  That depends.  If it’s Elop then I think he’ll do what Ballmer would do and ride Xbox to it’s death.  Other Microsoft candidates might do that, or path number 3.  I think an impartial external candidate (which I doubt will happen) would have the authority from the board (i.e. Bill Gates, which I doubt will happen) to make huge changes, including implementing path number 2.

I’m saddened by what’s happened to Xbox.  I hope there is a future for the console but I’m not very hopeful at the moment.  Here’s wishing that Microsoft proves me very wrong.

What I Want In A Windows 8.1 Touch Ultrabook

I’m shopping for a new Ultrabook at the moment to last me for the next 2 years and … well … I’m not very happy.  Let me list my requirements:

Haswell Processor

I want a 4th generation Intel Core i processor in my next computer.  I’m depressed by how many 3rd generation CPUs, Intel Celerons and even Pentiums are being sold on the market.  Seriously!?!?!  And OEMs wonder why their sales are falling?  They’re selling lots of shit!

I’m not even after an i7.  An i5 meets my requirements quite happily.

One of the benefits of Haswell: Miracast.

4-8 GB RAM

Nothing fancy there.  I don’t demo from my laptop any more because that’s impossible.

1920 * 1080 screen resolution

Unless you are a golden eagle, a 3200 * 1200 resolution screen will be pretty useless.  When you have to use Windows 8.1 scaling to make the screen usable, effectively bringing the screen resolution down, then mad screens make absolutely no sense to anyone but laptop bloggers and marketers.  Not to mention that the price of these mad Ultrabooks then gets pushed beyond an unrealistic €1800.

Touch

Yeah, I want a touch laptop.  I’ve ruled out otherwise superb machines as my next ultrabook because they don’t have a touch option.

Digitizer Support

Onenote is important to me.  But there are times when I need to draw … whiteboarding, or while taking notes.  No, the camera is not sufficient, otherwise I would, you know, use the camera.

Decent Keyboard

I write quite a bit.  Wet newspaper keyboards such as in the Acer S7 need not apply.

Full-Sized Touch Pad

I want a full sized touch pad with the buttons at the base.  Simple.  And I want a decent driver that is tuned by default to ignore accidental swipes while typing.  And I want the option to turn off Windows 8x gestures.

9+ Hours Battery

We were promised that Haswell processors would had 50% to battery life.  For the most part, the announced machines have not improved battery life.  It seems like the OEMs have cut corners to reduce costs, so 5-7 hours is often the advertised max.  Yes, there are exceptions, but they are exceptions. No need for you to contact me.

VGA

We live in a HDMI world.  Except we don’t.  I present for a living.  Only once have I had to option of connecting to a projector with something other than VGA – and that was because we especially brought in a high end projector to sell it at a trade show!  EVERY hotel and office I’ve been too only offers VGA.  Dongles cannot be depended upon, as I saw again yesterday when I had to borrow a laptop to present at E2EVC Rome.

Full-sized HDMI slot

Micro-HDMI slots are too loose.  Just give me a full sized slot so the cable doesn’t pop out if the dog next door barks.

256 GB SSD

128 GB is not enough.  No, I cannot live in the cloud because the cloud is not everywhere.

SD card slot

An absolute necessity for transfers from camera at speed.  I would love the card to be completely recessed into the machine, like in a camera.  That would make it almost like additional storage.

2 * USB 3.0

Why are companies putting USB 2.0 ports into their machines these days?

RJ45

Not a deal breaker, but I often have to connect to wired networks and once again, dongles cannot be relied upon.

Light & Thin

This is feasible, even with RJ45 and VGA as past Samsung models have shown.  My laptop needs to fit into my Airport Accelerator camera bag without catching the attention of cabin baggage size hawks at the airport.

TPM

I like to secure my laptop.

Support for Windows 8.1

Would you like to join me in the present?

SD card slot

An absolute necessity for transfers from camera at speed.  I would love the card to be completely recessed into the machine, like in a camera.  That would make it almost like additional storage.

Drivers

Share your drivers on your website.  Don’t make me install some crapware to download drivers.

Windows Product Key & Media

This one might be for MSFT.  I should have the right to create recovery media and install my machine.  Please include my product key either on the computer or on the PSU.  You listening Asus?

Other Stuff

After all that you can do your fancy screen twists, turns, disconnects, doo dads and all that jazz, but give me the option of a normal laptop too.

PRICE

How could I forget the price.  In an era when the APPLE MACBOOK AIR has become THE BUDGET OPTION for Ultrabook-style laptops, then you know that things are all messed up.  Nuff said.

I bet I am not alone in wanting the above.  But unfortunately, not one computer meets all those requirements.  Hell, it’s near impossible to even find a machine with Windows 8.1 and Haswell CPUs in the channel!!!  I know; I’ve looked!  I’ve gotten close.  Some otherwise great Ultrabooks fail my test for lack of touch.  It’s gotten so bad that I’ve considered a Macbook Air.  Right now, the Lenovo Yoga 2 is the best candidate, but it fails lots of my requirements too.

Technorati Tags: ,

Nokia Launches A Windows RT Tablet

In addition to 2 new Windows Phone tablets, Nokia launched “Sirius” which is officially called the Lumia 2520.  This is a Windows RT tablet.  On first impressions:

  • It looks much nicer than Surface 2
  • The camera looks impressive, even if it’s not a patch on what Nokia puts in the phones
  • Yes it is more expensive than Surface, but that’s because it includes an LTE modem, which usually adds $100 to the cost of a tablet.

All looks good but:

  • It runs Windows RT.  It might has well have a MIPS processor IMO.  I reckon Windows RT will be dead within 12-18 months of Ballmer leaving Microsoft, probably replaced by a rebranded Windows Phone on ARM devices (phones to 8” tablets).
  • It only has 32 GB storage.  Remember, that was the Surface RT that no one wanted, not that many wanted a Surface RT to begin with.  32 GB is just too small.  Nokia has a bad habit of screwing the pooch on storage, e.g. the Lumia 925 only has 16 GB.  And no, SkyDrive does not make up for this shortcoming.  LTE/3G is not omnipresent.
  • The keyboard cover is u-g-l-y.  Why the frak can’t they (Microsoft and Nokia) learn from the past and just do a clamshell keyboard that works, unlike the non-hinged unusable and space-inefficient stuff they repetitively throw at us?  The Nokia cover looks like one of those iPad covers from 3 years ago.
  • The Surface organisation will kill the Lumia tablet in a few months when MSFT gets the OK to take over Nokia.
Technorati Tags: ,

And Surface 2 Is GA … Sort Of

The second generation of Surface has gone live.  Surface RT becomes Surface 2 (Windows RT 8.1) and Surface Pro is Surface Pro 2 (Windows 8.1 Pro). 

Apparently, Seattle Seahawks ace cornerback, Richard Sherman, wants one. This is him in the Bellevue WA Microsoft Store.  Now I must buy an iPad in revenge!!!

The various Microsoft online stores have updated their range.  Some of the talked about accessories such as the power cover aren’t out until next year.  And the rumoured Surface Mini might not be out until late Spring.

At least distribution is better than it was a year ago.  Yes, the Microsoft brick’n’mortar stores (US only) and online stores (international) are selling the Surface.  A few direct-distribution chains such as BestBuy and PC World (DSG) have rights (though I don’t know if they have the 2 today).  And 5 of the mega-distributors have rights (also don’t know if they have the 2 today).  Sadly, the distributors who have lots of reach in local markets do not have distribution of Surface yet.

This morning (writing this early AM) will also see the launch of the Nokia Windows RT “Sirius” tablet, which I find more interesting than Surface 2, based purely on leaked info.  The presence of cellular (which adds to the cost) makes it more interesting for business uses, I think.

However, the newswires are already filled with iPad-mania.  Apple timed their next-gen launch to crush Microsoft and Nokia.  And it’s working based on what I’m hearing on the radio so far this morning.

Technorati Tags: ,

A Toshiba Z10t “Convertible Ultrabook” (Pro Tablet) Just Landed On My Desk

Look what just arrived:

IMAG0084

This is an Intel Core i5 processor powered Toshiba Z10t “tablet”, just like the Surface Pro is.  It docks into a clamshell rigid keyboard (no extra battery)

IMAG0086

Look Pa, no hands:

IMAG0088

And I don’t need to stand 6 foot 5 tall to get the thing to sit on my lap.  Yes, like all the pro tablets, it’s top heavy so it really needs a hand on the keyboard … but that’s where they coincidentally sit when I’m, you know, typing!

Toshiba don’t call this device a tablet.  I think that’s clever.  Say “tablet” to someone and they think $500 or less.  Put an i5, business level build, and a keyboard into a device and you’re talking $1000+.  That’s a big $500 (or more) psychological barrier to get over!

The tablet has a full-sized SD slot (handy for cameras) and USB 3.0 port.  The keyboard adds a USB 2.0 port, a full size HDMI port (they sit better than micro-HDMI), VGA (really needed for presenting at public venues), and RJ45.  It’s that last one that caught my eye when I played with one of these a while ago … that RJ45 means PXE BOOT!  And that means enterprise admin can deploy their Windows 8.1 Enterprise images to this machine using the network based tools that they are using for all other PC types.  This model that we got came with a digitizer stylus.  I find the stylus really useful for OneNote (drawing diagrams) and for using with the Isoboard app to white board via the projector (connected 99.9999% of the time via a VGA cable).

It came with Windows 8 Pro, so I’m upgrading it to Windows 8.1 Pro for demo purposes.

I reckon this is a good business offering for those looking for a hybrid tablet/laptop solution.  In my opinion, the true “lapability” of these device trounces the non-existence of this feature on Surface Pro and Surface Pro 2.

Hopefully I’ll get some time on this machine over the coming weeks/months so I can talk more about it.

Available on:

Surface 2 Package Versus Laptop & Tablet Combination

I read Paul Thurrot’s Surface 2 pricing article and I was startled when I started adding up the pieces for a solution I would want:

  • Surface Pro 2 (128 GB): $999
  • Docking station: $199.99
  • Power Cover: $199.99
  • Monitor: $250
  • Total: $1648.98

I have not included the cost of managing 1 device, for example, a System Center Client Management License, a Volume License “upgrade” for Windows. 

This solution is intended to be a single device solution: the Surface Pro 2 is:

  • The tablet: with the Power Cover providing somewhere between 10-12 total battery hours
  • The PC in the office: with docking station and monitor
  • The laptop: with the Power Cover providing the keyboard

Note: Windows Intune and Office Pro Plus (via Office 356) are per user licenses for up to 5 devices.  There’s no point in adding these because quantity of devices for comparison purposes does not matter – I am still one person requiring one license for Intune and one license for O365, whether I have 1 device or 5 devices.

How does the above package compare with a more traditional solution with a laptop/tablet package?

  • HP EliteBook Folio 9470m (500 GB / 8.5 hrs battery): $1049
  • Toshiba Encore (8” Windows 8.1 tablet): $329
  • Monitor: $250
  • Total: $1628

I went with a “thin and light” business laptop from HP and chose one of the more economic options.  Quite honestly, you could go for a traditional laptop and pay $649 or spec up and pay $1858.  I chose the Toshiba tablet because they were the only name I saw (without much search effort to be honest) that I would associate with business customers.

So how do we compare:

  • The Surface Pro 2 solution with the Power Cover has more battery life than the pre-Haswell HP laptop.  I’m sure a Haswell laptop could correct this, but it seems like lots of OEMs so far (based on IFA announcements) have been lazy or skimming the battery because advancements, more often than not, are not as good as expected.
  • The laptop/tablet person has twice as many chargers to lose, and stuff to carry.  If they leave the laptop behind then they have trouble typing.  Note: typing on the lap, even with the new kickstand, will continue to be impossible.  If the old kickstand went beyond my knees, then a kickstand that sticks out more solves that … exactly how?  Has Surface perfected the warping of space?  Can I use one near the Large Hadron Collider without causing a black hole?
  • The pricing is not that different in the package.  Spec down the laptop and the business spends less.  Spec up the laptop and the Surface package is more efficient – my gut tells me this is the more realistic scenario of the 3.
  • Sync has become an issue: One Surface = one set of files.  2 devices and I need to Sync.  Sure, I’ll have Skydrive … and Skydrive Pro, and Workplace Folders … and isn’t it confusing now?

As a business user, I like the “one Surface” option, economically speaking.  As a user, I’m probably going to go with PC (for photo editing), ultrabook for mobile productivity, and 8” tablet (of some OS kind, and leaning towards iPad Mini with Cellular) because I do like to use the right tool for the job rather than a generalist solution.

I don’t consider the Surface Pro as a solution for me.  The device cannot be used on a lap unless you are 6-5 tall.  I know I’ll get the usual tweet from the usual 1 or 2 Surface fans on this.  I’ve tried it (we have an RT and a Pro here).  The new hinge just cannot solve the typing with a keyboard issue – the laws of physics are pretty clear.  I want a detachable clamshell keyboard with a stiff hinge that gives me a laptop/hybrid solution.  And why oh why doesn’t the Surface keyboard stay shut with magnets?  Why do I have to hold it closed?

Anyway, while the Surface Pro 2 is not for me, I do see it being viable for many business users if they go down the 1 device for users, rather than the traditional “here’s a PC, here’s a laptop, and here’s a tablet” approach that has evolved.

Technorati Tags: ,,

Surface 2 Announcement Is Today – More Of The Same And A Future Prediction

The pre-release launch or announcement of the Microsoft Surface generation 2 is today at 10:30 EST or 15:30 GMT.  I don’t have a live stream link, if there will even be one.

At this point, “leaks” (personally I think they are deliberate drip feeds to generate interest) have given us a fairly good view of what’s coming in the second generation of Surface:

  • A mini 8” tablet that will be released in 2014
  • Surface RT (aka Surface 2) and Surface Pro (aka Surface Pro 2) will get a new processor and come with Windows 8.1.  No new chassis, etc.  The kickstand will have 2 positions.
  • Some new colours in the keyboards (uhhhh), a cover keyboard with a battery, and a dock-able keyboard.

In other words, mostly more of the same.  The worst rumour of all is that the Surface 2 and Surface Pro 2 will come in at the original release prices of the 1st generation Surfaces.  Yes, the price that everyone said was way too much.

And that’s why we’ve been seeing the Einstein insanity quote over and over and over and over for the last few weeks:

Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

This whole Surface thing makes me wonder if anyone in Redmond has realised that Surface just is not working.

Surface Pro 2

A $999 Surface Pro 2 is essentially an Ultrabook with no battery, a small (6 hours allegedly) battery life, and a now modest storage of up to 128 GB (easily consumed once you install a few programs and sync Skydrive).  Meanwhile entry level Ultrabooks are getting cheaper and the higher end devices leave the Surface behind.  But no, you cry, the Surface Pro 2 is a tablet!

OK, I can get the much-desired iPad 64 GB (to compare like with like) for $699.  But realistically, the 32 GB will be fine and that costs $599, has a 10 hour battery, has lots of apps (apps are more important than programs on a tablet), and has a thriving used market (buy one, use it, sell it, and not lose too much when you buy a newer generation o

ne a year or two later).  As a consumer buy the iPad is way more attractive.  And then there’s the Android tablets that are coming in at an even lower price.

Wait no, the Surface Pro 2 is a hybrid.  And there it fails again because it is unusable as a productivity device on your lap, on a plan in anything lower than business class, and in a train where tables are even smaller than in economy on a short-haul flight.  We’ll see if the new dock-able keyboard solves that, but I suspect it is a hack that will work as well as the third-party iPad keyboard solutions (which suck).

Surface 2

Windows on ARM is dead, it just doesn’t know it yet.  Every third party manufacturer has jumped of the platform – Nokia is effectively Microsoft now so we discount them.  MSFT marketing will scream that ARM is strategic and thriving but it has as much life in it as Windows NT on MIPS processors or Windows Server on Itanium.  And let’s face it, a low spec 32 GB tablet (with 10 GB usable) that costs $499 hasn’t a snowball’s chance in hell in selling.  Whey the hell would a person at home who wants a content consumption tablet ever buy a lower spec device when they can get a desirable 16 GB iPad for just $10 more?

Surface 2 needs to drastically increase in spec or cost $250 to have a chance, and even then, that will only work when the app market improves by 500%.  Note that improve is not a statement of quantity but it is a measure of substance and quality.

Dump ARM or Switch To “Sirius”

If I was running whatever the devices organization is called these days in Microsoft, I could trash all efforts on ARM right now.  It was tried and it failed miserably.  Intel Atom is the best bet for low end consumer consumption devices (Haswell Intel Core i is just too expensive and tablets are eating PC’s lunch in retail for the last 18 months).

If I couldn’t dump ARM then I’d stop Surface 2 and switch to the Nokia “Sirius”.  This is a nicer looking 10” tablet that Nokia was working on, also based on Windows RT and was due to be announced around now.  I’d make 2 changes to it:

  1. Increase the storage from 32 GB.  10 GB free space is NOTHING.  It’s $120 no-name Android device territory.
  2. Offer a model that does not include the LTE modem to have a cheaper model.
  3. Increase the screen resolution from the Windows 8 default of 1366 x 768, so the tablet isn’t immediately slammed by consumer reviewers.

The Sirius (codename) costs $499 because it comes with an LTE modem.  Some have said this is too expensive.  Note that adding a modem to an iPad adds $130.

Prediction

In Q3 next year (Q1 in the Microsoft financial year), Microsoft will announce a stock discount that will make the recent $900m write down look like a drop in the water.  Windows RT will be killed.  Heads will roll.  And all this will happen just after Ballmer steps down at WPC, giving the new CEO the opportunity to clean sweep.  And then someone will do what should have been done 3 years ago: Windows Phone, a non-hybrid OS, will be ported to support consumer (content consumption) ARM tablets.